Archmage Callinon wrote:
Quote:
They listen to their fans opinions. Have they? I haven't seen any listening.
The. Hunt.
Pretty much everyone admits they dropped the ball on that system and misinterpreted what people were wanting (since this game can't support any actual "tough" overworld encounters) which is why early on it died out QUICKLY until they kept making adjustments, then later added the Twine/Coat book to drop tables which made people actually want to do them again. Wanderer's Palace Hard Mode is much more accurate in "listening", since people have been wanting to know more and see more of the Mamool Ja seeing as it's a FFXI beastmen race just randomly in Eorzea. (That Yoshi himself wanted added, so we can't really rely on the "relic of tanaka" argument people still use.)
Quote:
That's an entire system that exists only because people asked for it and not for any other reason.
Actually, they did it as filler content when it was introduced because he stated as clear as day they never had plans to do it and it was a last minute addition which is why he even apologized at the fact it feels like something just tossed together and they've been adjusting it Ontop of that it also was a good way to introduce more glamor and various non-essential items with the exception of a few (like purchasable alexandrites). So it was a popular request, much like a popular request was to stop shoving FATEs on us and a quick browse through OF between 2.0 - 2.5 era, plenty of people always mentioned having less reliance on FATEs, especially in seasonal events, but as we can see with the "timeline" for HW, plenty more FATEs await us. It's a core game system, but so are Leves (that remains ignored largely) and they could even reintroduce "Behest" as the continuation to Guldhests.
Quote:
I don't remember this, what poll are you talking about? In any event, having an Ivalice race suddenly pop up in Eorzea would be a little strange. The Vana'diel races are in here only because Tanaka was a creative black hole.
The poll was during 1.x when they asked what kind of races would we like to see. The one with Viera won because...it had Viera as an example, it was never promised but the type of race was promised. He admitted using Viera skewed the results because people thought they meant adding Viera.
Human, Elf, Midget, Hulk (various 5th race here.) That's not a blackhole, that's the general template and these races now are largely the "FF Online" races because they stated as plain as day (both Tanaka (when asked about adding new races from other games in the series) and Yoshi) they didn't want people to think this takes place in Ivalice, which is why using any other race from the FF series would give that illusion. There's not many races out there you can use in an MMO that doesn't make it seem like a creative blackhole. I bet you can load up plenty of MMOs and see similiar races or variants of the usual races. The "general races" you see in every MMO simply fits that world, which is why even demonic type races are rarely added, because the world doesn't support having random devils/demons and so on just living about 3 fields away from the holy Elfen race.
Quote:
The word "lie" implies that Yoshi P was being deceptive.
He said it would be separate from FC housing and not cost anywhere near as much. The main thing that irked people was it were the same lots and same lot price. If it was cheaper people wouldn't mind as much. Not to mention Personal Housing is no different from FC housing because it's essentially the same. In other MMOs, you could share housing with your marriage partner, or a group of friends and the houses even gives you buffs (which in ARR, the FC actions take care of) so it definitely did come across as a "lie" when it was basically Free Company houses you can buy solo.
Quote:
I think he just ended up being wrong.
Considering he made it a point to say: "Everything goes through me before it enters the game", I don't think he "ended up wrong", he just didn't want to go back on his word last minute when HE gave the ok to make it essentially the same system as FC housing and same lot prices (being that it's the same lots.)
Housing I care nothing for until they actually start enhancing your gameplay experience, but at the same time, I can definitely see why it pissed people off.
Quote:
Remember when people were complaining about contested Oils and Sands through ST? People complained about that and SE created the weekly quest system. (Solved one of their own problems too: Getting people to do old Crystal Tower runs again.)
This was just people being whiny because they could have done T6 and T7 and gotten all 3 of those items and quite honestly, quicker than what happens in ST a lot (at the time.)
The weekly didn't really solve much because LoTA still takes a long time (no reason to queue it after your quest), when Yoshida did say the items would be on a separate lockout, which people though it would be similar to ST where WoD will drop it (which Yoshida had said would have multiple routes and your loot varies depending on which route you took.)
In reality, the only thing the weekly did was allow people who can't clear "harder content (FCoB is arguable on difficulty until 13)" to get I130, which would have been the same effect as adding it to WoD loot tables because the weird itemization in this game made it so WoD actually drops a few BiS pieces compared to the I130 variants. So if one route was the usual loot tables (Demon gear) you could choose to go the other route (Augmented Magitek Materials) - That was perfect, rather than forcing us back into content people rightfully left behind due to vertical progression (I've seen no one asked to go back to LoTA or ST.) This is why people got excited as **** when they seen "allagan Catalyst" because it seemed like it could have been either a variant of upgrade item (collect - turn in for such) that dropped from WoD or the item for the CT weapons that too dropped from WoD since we knew there would be a gap between 2.5 and expansion content wise, so people figured they'd keep WoD as relevant as possible.
Who knows, the patch tonight might change more than FCoB nerfs in terms of distribution.