'I think this creature is getting bolder, and it could be he is not willing to settle for fish anymore. That he is now climbing through windows in search of cradles tells me that even two barrels of fish might not be enough to dissuade him from trying it again.
'If we place these fish beneath the open window of Garbert's cottage, I reckon we might surprise him when he returns to try for the cradle again.
'Let me know when you are ready to go, name, and we can prepare.'
Wistan has devised a new plan for catching the sneaking creature, and he will need your help to carry it out.
Talk to Wistan and carry out his plan to capture the creature
Wistan is at his campfire at Echad Candelleth, in Tâl Bruinen.
Wistan is waiting to travel with you to Garbert's cottage to carry out his plan to capture the creature.
Talk to Wistan
Wistan is at his campfire at Echad Candelleth, the Elf-camp in Tâl Bruinen.
The hunter Wistan is waiting to speak with you about the events of the night.
Another reward for the quest is the fact that you get to see Gollum!